Regulatory & Claims11·2026-11-07

Workshop Health and Safety: Duties, Fines and Cover

What HSWA expects of garages, panel shops and dealerships, what changes on 1 April 2027, and why statutory liability cover cannot pay a WorkSafe fine.

A vehicle workshop is one of the more hazardous small workplaces in the country. Cars are lifted overhead on hoists, technicians work underneath tonnes of steel, spray painters handle isocyanate paints, and the floor is shared with moving vehicles, compressed air, welding gear and flammable liquids. When something goes wrong, the consequences land on the business in two separate ways: a regulator that can prosecute, and a balance sheet that has to absorb the cost of responding.

This guide sets out what the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015 (HSWA) expects of garages, panel shops, tyre shops and dealerships, what is changing when the 2026 amendments take effect on 1 April 2027, what has to happen after a serious incident, and where insurance fits. It also covers one point that surprises many business owners: no insurance policy can lawfully pay a fine imposed under HSWA.

The Core Duty on Every Workshop

Under HSWA, the business itself is a PCBU, a person conducting a business or undertaking. WorkSafe's introduction to HSWA summarises the primary duty of care in section 36: a PCBU must ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, the health and safety of workers. That covers employees, apprentices, contractors and labour hire staff, and it extends to other people affected by the work, such as customers in a reception area or someone collecting a car from the yard.

Two further duties matter particularly in the motor trade. A PCBU that manages or controls a workplace must ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, that the workplace and the ways in and out of it are without risk (section 37). A PCBU that manages or controls fixtures, fittings or plant must ensure they are without risks to the health and safety of any person (section 38). In a workshop, plant means hoists, compressors, wheel balancers, tyre changers, presses, spray booths and diagnostic equipment. Keeping that equipment inspected, maintained and used properly is part of the legal duty, not just good practice.

Officers carry their own obligation. The same WorkSafe guide explains that officers, such as company directors, must exercise due diligence to make sure the PCBU complies with its duties (section 44). In a small family-owned garage, the owner is usually both the PCBU's officer and a worker on the floor, which means the duty is personal.

All PCBUs must also engage with their workers on health and safety matters. In practice that means asking the technicians who use the hoists and the painters who use the booth what they think the risks are, and acting on what they say.

The Hazards WorkSafe Points To

WorkSafe's page on risk in collision repair lists the main hazards for that part of the trade, and most of them apply to mechanical workshops as well. It names machinery, including the risk of vehicle hoists collapsing and harm from welding fumes; dust from sanding; noise that can cause hearing loss over time; fires and explosions from flammable gases and vapours, with spray booths needing regular servicing and filter replacement; vehicles, including people being trapped between a vehicle and a structure or being struck by one; and the misuse of compressed air.

Spray painting deserves particular attention. A guide on working safely with hazardous substances in collision repair workshops, published on WorkSafe's site, states that exposure to isocyanates causes asthma and that spray painters are therefore at high risk of developing it. It notes that two-part paints, sealers and lacquers are likely to contain isocyanates, recommends doing all spraying inside the booth, even quick touch-ups, and says a properly maintained supplied-air respirator gives better protection than cartridge types. That guide dates from 2014, before HSWA, so treat it as practical guidance rather than a statement of current regulations.

The pattern across these hazards is that most serious workshop injuries come from a small number of predictable sources: something heavy falling, someone being caught or crushed, a fire, or long-term exposure to fumes, dust and noise.

What Changes on 1 April 2027

Parliament passed the Health and Safety at Work Amendment Bill on 1 July 2026. According to WorkSafe's guide to understanding the changes, the changes come into effect on 1 April 2027. Three of them are directly relevant to workshops.

The first is a focus on critical risks. WorkSafe describes a critical risk as one that is likely to lead to death, a notifiable injury, illness or incident, or a notifiable occupational disease. Its examples include activities where objects could fall or be dropped onto people, plant with moving parts or the potential for mechanical failure, and the use of hazardous substances. A car on a hoist, a press, a tyre cage and a spray booth all sit comfortably inside those categories.

The second is a split between small and large businesses. WorkSafe's guide on small and large PCBUs says a small PCBU has fewer than 20 workers, and that workers include employees, contractors, subcontractors and labour hire workers. From 1 April 2027, a small PCBU's main duties are limited to managing critical risks, while a large PCBU must manage all risks and prioritise the critical ones. Most independent garages will be small PCBUs, but a workshop's critical risks are its most important risks, so the practical workload is unlikely to shrink much.

The third concerns officers and codes of practice. WorkSafe says officer duties are being clarified to focus on governance: understanding the relevant risks, making sure the business has the resources and processes to manage them, and verifying those resources and processes are being used. It also says that from 1 April 2027 a business that follows an approved code of practice is considered to have met its HSWA obligations for the relevant risk. Following a code is still not mandatory, but it becomes a much clearer way to show compliance.

None of this removes the existing offences or penalties, and nothing in the changes alters the rule on insuring fines discussed below.

After a Serious Incident: Notification and the Scene

When something serious happens, HSWA sets out what must happen next. WorkSafe's page on what events need to be notified says a PCBU must make sure the regulator is notified as soon as possible, using the fastest method available, and that notification is required even if emergency services attend. For a work-related death, WorkSafe asks to be called immediately on 0800 030 040.

Notifiable injuries include amputation of any part of the body, a serious head injury, a serious eye injury, a serious burn, serious deep cuts, spinal injury and loss of consciousness from a work-related cause, such as exposure to a harmful substance. Notifiable incidents include fire or explosion; the escape, spill or leak of a substance, gas or pressurised substance; a fall or release from height of plant, a substance or an object, with WorkSafe giving the example of a heavy item falling from a shelf or hoist; and the collapse, overturning or malfunction of certain plant that must be authorised for use. A car dropping off a hoist can be a notifiable incident even if nobody is hurt.

The PCBU that manages or controls the workplace must take all reasonable steps to make sure the site is not disturbed until an inspector allows work to resume, apart from exceptions such as helping an injured person or making the site safe. Work can continue elsewhere in the workplace. Records of notifiable events must be kept for at least five years from the date the regulator was notified.

From an insurance point of view, the first hours matter too. Most liability policies require prompt notice of any incident that could lead to a claim or an investigation. Telling your adviser and insurer early, and keeping your own record of what happened, protects your position if a prosecution or civil claim follows months later.

What the Penalties Look Like

WorkSafe's page on offences and penalties sets out three tiers of offence. For a company, the maximum fine is $3 million for reckless conduct in respect of a duty (section 47), $1.5 million for failing to comply with a duty in a way that exposes a person to a risk of death or serious injury or illness (section 48), and $500,000 for failing to comply with a duty (section 49). An individual PCBU or an officer faces maximum fines of $600,000, $300,000 and $100,000 respectively for the same three offences, and a section 47 offence can also carry up to five years' imprisonment.

Regulators can also issue infringement notices for specified offences, and courts can make further orders, including orders requiring the offender to put right the effects of the offence.

The Rule That Surprises Business Owners

Section 29 of HSWA makes insurance against fines unlawful. WorkSafe's introduction to HSWA puts it plainly: insurance policies cannot be used to pay fines or infringement fees imposed under HSWA, and it is an offence to offer or enter into an insurance policy to pay a fine or infringement fee. The same guide adds that insurance can be used to make reparation payments ordered by the court as part of a sentence.

That shapes what statutory liability insurance can and cannot do. A statutory liability policy is designed to respond when a business is investigated or prosecuted for an unintentional breach of legislation. Depending on the wording, it may cover legal defence costs, the cost of responding to an investigation and court-ordered reparation to a victim. It cannot cover the HSWA fine itself. Any suggestion that a policy will pay a WorkSafe fine should be treated as a red flag, and the wording should be checked carefully with your adviser.

Defence costs alone can be substantial. A prosecution may run for many months and involve lawyers, expert witnesses and engineering reports on the equipment involved. For a small workshop, those costs can be as damaging as the penalty.

Where ACC Fits

People are often unsure why a workshop needs liability cover when ACC covers injuries. ACC's overview for employers explains that if an employee is injured at work, it does not matter whose fault it is or how it happens, and that employers must pay compensation of no less than 80% of earnings for the employee's first week off work.

So ACC deals with the injured person's treatment, rehabilitation and most of their lost earnings. It does not deal with the regulatory side of the incident: the WorkSafe investigation, the legal costs of defending a prosecution, or a reparation order. Nor does it repair a damaged hoist, replace a burnt-out spray booth or cover the income lost while a bay sits idle under a site-preservation requirement. Those gaps are what statutory liability, property and business interruption cover are for.

Insurance Sections Worth Reviewing

A workshop health and safety review is a good moment to look at the insurance programme alongside it. Statutory liability is the obvious starting point: check the limit, whether defence costs erode it, whether reparation is included, and how the policy defines an investigation. Some wordings exclude deliberate or reckless breaches, which is consistent with the law, but it makes the quality of your everyday safety systems directly relevant to whether cover responds.

Directors and officers cover can matter where a company is involved, because officers carry their own HSWA duty. Property and machinery breakdown cover should reflect the replacement value of hoists, booths and diagnostic equipment. Business interruption cover should consider how long a bay or a whole workshop could be out of action after a fire, an equipment failure or an incident site being held for an inspector. Public liability remains relevant for injuries to customers and visitors.

Practical Steps That Help on Both Fronts

The same habits that keep people safe also make a business easier to insure and easier to defend. Keep a written inspection and maintenance record for every hoist and item of plant, and take a hoist out of service the moment a fault is found. Keep safety data sheets and an inventory for every hazardous substance on site. Make sure all spraying happens in the booth, that booth filters are changed on schedule, and that respiratory protection is suitable and maintained. Set and enforce rules for moving vehicles inside the workshop and yard. Record induction and training for every new worker, including apprentices and contractors, and talk to workers regularly about what they think could go wrong.

When the 2027 changes arrive, work out whether you are a small or large PCBU, identify your critical risks, and check whether an approved code of practice applies to any of them. The amendments make a documented, risk-focused approach more valuable than ever.

Getting the Right Cover

Health and safety law sets the duties, and insurance cannot buy your way out of them. What it can do is fund the defence, the reparation and the business disruption that follow a serious incident, so that one bad day does not end the business. If you would like your statutory liability or wider motor trade programme reviewed, use the Get a Quote form and tell us about your workshop. Questions can also go to hello@cover4you.co.nz.

Get Your Motor Trade Insurance Quote Today

Submit your details and a specialist adviser will be in touch — straightforward advice, no hard sell, ever.

Get a Quote
Licensed NZ advisersNo obligation, no hard sellMotor trade specialistsCallback within one business day